The development of an integrated environment-human risk approach for the prioritisation of antibiotics for policy decisions

Abstract

Environmental contamination with antibiotic residues has caused significant concern. Antibiotics are continually emitted into the environment which potentially threatens environmental and human health, particularly, the risk in the development of antibiotic resistance. A list of priority antibiotics in the environment is essential for eco-pharmacovigilance and policy decisions. This study developed a prioritisation system of antibiotics based on their integrated environmental (resistance and ecotoxicity) and human health (resistance and toxicity) risks, considering various aquatic environmental compartments. Data obtained by conducting a systematic review of the literature of antibiotic residues in various aquatic environmental compartments in China was used as an example. The list of priority antibiotics was created by ranking the antibiotics in descending order, based on the risk scores of their a) overall risk, (b) antibiotic resistance risk to environment, (c) ecotoxicity risk, (d) overall environmental risk, (e) antibiotic resistance risk to human health, (f) toxicity risk to human health and (g) overall human health risk. Ciprofloxacin posed the greatest risk and chloramphenicol posed the least risk. The output from this research can be used to implement eco-pharmacovigilance and to develop targeted policies which would prevent / minimise the environmental and human health risks from antibiotic residues. The use of this list of priority antibiotics will allow for a country / region / setting to (a) optimise the use of antibiotics and their prescribing practices, (b) create effective monitoring and mitigation strategies, (c) minimise the discharge of antibiotic residues and (d) focus research efforts.

Keywords: Antibiotic prioritisation system; Antibiotic residues; Antibiotic resistance; Environmental risk; Human health risk; Integrated quantitative assessment; Toxicity.