There are no international guidelines for brain biopsy in neurological disease of unknown etiology, yet most practicing neurologists will encounter difficult cases in which biopsy is considered. This patient cohort is heterogenous, and it is unclear in which circumstances biopsy is most useful. We performed an audit of brain biopsies reviewed in our neuropathology department from 2010 to 2021. Of 9,488 biopsies, 331 biopsies undertaken for an undiagnosed neurological disease were identified. Where documented, the commonest symptoms were hemorrhage, encephalopathy, and dementia. 29% of biopsies were non-diagnostic. The most common clinically relevant findings on biopsy were infection, cerebral amyloid angiopathy with or without angiitis, and demyelination. Rarer conditions included CNS vasculitis, non-infectious encephalitis, and Creutzfeldt Jakob Disease. We highlight the value of brain biopsy in the workup of cryptogenic neurological disease despite recent advances in less invasive diagnostics.