Brief Report: Comparative Analysis of Pre-existing HIV Drug Resistance Mutations in Proviral DNA Using Next-Generation Sequencing and Routine HIV RNA Genotyping

Abstract

Background: We investigated whether deep sequencing of archived HIV DNA of antiretroviral-naive persons with acute/early HIV infection could identify transmitted drug resistance mutations (DRM), per the IAS drug resistance algorithm, which are not detected by routine bulk (consensus) sequencing.

Methods: Deep sequencing of HIV DNA from peripheral blood mononuclear cells and consensus sequencing from concurrent blood plasma (BP) was performed from antiretroviral (ART)-naive adults with recent infection. We compared the prevalence of low-frequency (2%-20%) and high-frequency (>20%) nonnucleoside reverse transcriptase inhibitor (NNRTI), nucleoside reverse transcriptase inhibitor (NRTI), and protease inhibitor (PI) DRM.

Results: Overall, 190 individuals were included, 72 (37.9%) with acute, 20 (10.5%) with very early, and 98 (51.6%) with recent HIV infection. Although all DRM detected in plasma appeared in archived proviral DNA, 9 high-frequency mutations were only detected in HIV DNA. These included 3 NRTI mutations, 4 NNRTI mutations, 1 PI mutation, and 1 H221Y (associated rilpivirine resistance) mutation. When considering DRM <20%, 11 NNRTI, 7 NRTI, 6 PI, and 3 F227L (associated doravirine resistance) mutations were found exclusively in HIV DNA. Interestingly, although 2 high-frequency M184V appeared in both DNA and RNA, low-frequency M184I were exclusive to HIV DNA (n = 6). No participants experienced virologic failure after initiating ART during the median 25.39 ± 3.13 months of follow-up on treatment.

Conclusion: Although most high-frequency DRMs were consistently detected in HIV RNA and HIV DNA, the presence of low-frequency DRM in proviral DNA may be relevant for clinicians because these mutations could become dominant under drug selection pressure.