Purpose: There is still a lack of effective treatments for cartilage damage. Cartilage tissue engineering could be a promising treatment method. Human umbilical cord Wharton's jelly (HUCWJ) and hydrogels have received wide attention as a scaffold for tissue engineering. They have not been widely used in clinical studies as their effectiveness and safety are still controversial. This study systematically compared the ability of these two biological tissue engineering materials to carry chondrocytes to repair cartilage injury in vivo. Methods: Chondrocytes were cocultured with HUCWJ or hydrogel for in vivo transplantation. The treatments comprised the HUCWJ+cell, hydrogel+cell, and blank groups. A rabbit model with articular cartilage defect in the knee joint area was established. The defective knee cartilage of different rabbit groups was treated for 3 and 6 months. The efficacy of the various treatments on articular cartilage injury was evaluated by immunohistochemistry and biochemical indices. Results: We found that the HUCWJ+cell and hydrogel+cell groups promoted cartilage repair compared with the blank group, which had no repair effect. The treatment efficacy of each group at 6 months was significantly better than that at 3 months. HUCWJ showed accelerated cartilage repair ability than the hydrogel. Conclusion: This study showed that HUCWJ is useful in cartilage tissue engineering to enhance the efficacy of chondrocyte-based cartilage repair, providing new insights for regenerative medicine. Impact statement Human umbilical cord Wharton's jelly (HUCWJ) and hydrogel are the suitable extracellular matrix for cartilage tissue engineering. This study assessed the capacity of HUCWJ- and hydrogel-loaded chondrocytes to repair cartilage injury in vivo. The data demonstrate that both HUCWJ and hydrogel effectively facilitated cartilage repair, and the repair effects of HUCWJ were significantly better compared with hydrogel, therefore providing a potential candidate for clinical practice of cartilage regeneration therapy.
Keywords: HUCWJ; biological tissue engineering; cartilage repair; chondrocytes; hydrogel.