Open vs robotic intracorporeal Padua ileal bladder: functional outcomes of a single-centre RCT

Abstract

Purpose: Functional outcomes of robot-assisted (RA) radical cystectomy (RC) with intracorporeal orthotopic neobladder (i-ON) have been poorly investigated. The study aimed to report functional outcomes of a prospective randomized controlled trial (RCT) comparing open RC (ORC) and RARC with i-ON.

Methods: Inclusion criteria were cT2-4/N0/M0, or BCG-failure high-grade urothelial carcinoma, candidate to RC with curative intent. A covariate adaptive randomization process was used, based on the following variables: BMI, ASA score, haemoglobin levels, cT-stage, neoadjuvant chemotherapy, urinary diversion. Day-time continence was defined as "totally dryness", nigh-time continence as pad wetness ≤ 50 cc. Continence recovery probabilities were compared between arms with Kaplan-Meier method and Cox regression analysis was performed to identify predictors of continence recovery. HRQoL outcomes analysis was assessed with a generalized linear mixed effect regression (GLMER) model.

Results: Out of 116 patients randomized, 88 received ON. Quantitative analysis of functional outcomes reported similar results in terms of day continence, while a better night continence status in ORC cohort was observed. However, 1-yr day- and night-time continence recovery probabilities were comparable. Night-time micturition frequency < 3 h was the only predictor of nigh-time continence recovery. At GLMER, 1-yr body image and sexual functioning were significantly better in RARC cohort, while urinary symptoms were comparable between arms.

Conclusion: Despite superiority of ORC at quantitative night-time pad use analysis, we showed comparable day- and night-time continence recovery probabilities. At 1-yr analysis of HRQoL outcomes, urinary symptoms were comparable between arms, while RARC patients reported lower body image and sexual functioning worsening.

Keywords: Functional outcomes; Open surgery; Orthotopic neobladders; Radical cystectomy; Randomized controlled trial; Robotic surgery; Urinary continence.