Novel Insights in the Management of Vernal Keratoconjunctivitis (VKC): European Expert Consensus Using a Modified Nominal Group Technique

Ophthalmol Ther. 2023 Apr;12(2):1207-1222. doi: 10.1007/s40123-023-00665-5. Epub 2023 Feb 15.

Abstract

Introduction: Vernal keratoconjunctivitis (VKC) is a rare, severe allergic ocular disease, typically occurring in children and adolescents, that can have a significant impact on quality of life and lead to visual impairment. Long-term treatment may be necessary to tackle chronic inflammation and topical corticosteroid dependency must be minimised due to the risk of complications. There is a need for unified clinical guidance to aid the assessment, diagnosis and management of VKC across Europe. The aim of this expert panel (the EUR-VKC Group) was to provide clear guidance for primary care physicians and general ophthalmologists involved in the diagnosis and management of VKC.

Methods: An expert group of seven European ophthalmologists was convened and a modified nominal group technique used to develop key recommendations on VKC management. The recommendations were subject to up to two rounds of voting using a 5-point Likert scale to ascertain consensus and the strength of each recommendation. Consensus was set at a predetermined threshold of ≥ 75.0% of experts selecting 'Strongly agree' or 'Agree'.

Results: A total of 47 recommendations were developed relating to the assessment of key of VKC, guidance on who and when to refer, as well as treatment-escalation pathways, long-term follow-up, and supportive care and education. All recommendations reached consensus after two rounds. The group emphasise how timely diagnosis and treatment initiation that is appropriate to disease severity are crucial to benefit patients with VKC. Patients with signs ('red flags') indicating severe VKC, or persistent mild-to-moderate VKC that is non-responsive following 2-4 weeks of treatment, should be referred to a sub-specialist.

Conclusion: The EUR-VKC Group provides recommendations on the assessment, diagnosis, management, referral and follow-up of patients with VKC. It also provides a framework to facilitate collaboration between primary care physicians, general ophthalmologists and sub-specialists to improve the outcomes for patients with VKC.

Keywords: Consensus; Europe; Expert panel method; Management; VKC; Vernal keratoconjunctivitis.

Plain language summary

Vernal keratoconjunctivitis (VKC) is a rare, underdiagnosed, chronic allergic eye disease that typically occurs in children and adolescents. If left untreated, VKC can significantly damage the eye, potentially leading to long-term complications, visual impairment and a reduced quality of life for the child and their family and/or caregivers. In the absence of established guidelines, this consensus programme set out to gather expert insights on best practices for assessing and managing VKC across Europe. A group of seven European ophthalmologists engaged in the consensus programme. A total of 47 recommendations were developed relating to the assessment, diagnosis, management, referral and follow-up of patients with VKC. These 47 recommendations underwent two rounds of review and were revised, if necessary, following expert input. Recommendations where ≥ 75.0% of experts agreed were considered as having reached consensus and were included as final recommendations. The experts agreed that VKC can be classified as mild, moderate or severe, and should be managed according to severity in a stepwise manner, with treatment intensity escalating as the disease severity increases. Timely diagnosis and treatment initiation appropriate to the severity of VKC are crucial to prevent sight loss and improve the quality of life of children with VKC. Ongoing treatment may be necessary to tackle the chronic inflammation associated with the disease and, therefore, reliance on steroid eye drops should be reduced to avoid an increased risk of well-known complications. The experts concluded that mild VKC can be assessed and managed in primary care, but patients with severe VKC, or with moderate-to-severe VKC that does not respond to treatment within 2–4 weeks, should be referred to a VKC specialist.