Myotonic dystrophy is a multisystemic neuromuscular disease caused by either a CTG repeat expansion in DMPK (DM1) or a CCTG repeat expansion in CNBP (DM2). Transcription of the expanded alleles produces toxic gain-of-function RNA that sequester the MBNL family of alternative splicing regulators into ribonuclear foci, leading to pathogenic mis-splicing. There are currently no approved treatments that target the root cause of disease which is the production of the toxic expansion RNA molecules. In this study, using our previously established HeLa DM1 repeat selective screening platform, we identified the natural product quercetin as a selective modulator of toxic RNA levels. Quercetin treatment selectively reduced toxic RNA levels and rescued MBNL dependent mis-splicing in DM1 and DM2 patient derived cell lines and in the HSALR transgenic DM1 mouse model where rescue of myotonia was also observed. Based on our data and its safety profile for use in humans, we have identified quercetin as a priority disease-targeting therapeutic lead for clinical evaluation for the treatment of DM1 and DM2.