Nursing Home Status Adjustment for Standardized Mortality and Hospitalization in Dialysis Facility Reports

Shu Chen; Megan Slowey; Valarie B Ashby; Lonnie Barnes; Aaron Pearson; Jian Kang; Joseph M Messana

doi:10.1016/j.xkme.2022.100580

Nursing Home Status Adjustment for Standardized Mortality and Hospitalization in Dialysis Facility Reports

Kidney Med. 2022 Dec 8;5(2):100580. doi: 10.1016/j.xkme.2022.100580. eCollection 2023 Feb.

Authors

Shu Chen^{1

2}, Megan Slowey^{1

2}, Valarie B Ashby^{1

2}, Lonnie Barnes¹, Aaron Pearson^{1

2}, Jian Kang^{1

2}, Joseph M Messana^{1

3}

Affiliations

¹ Kidney Epidemiology and Cost Center, University of Michigan, Ann Arbor, Michigan.
² Department of Biostatistics, University of Michigan, Ann Arbor, Michigan.
³ Department of Internal Medicine-Nephrology Division, University of Michigan, Ann Arbor, Michigan.

Abstract

Rationale & objective: Compared to the original nursing home status (any nursing home stay in the previous calendar year), new nursing home status variables were developed to improve the risk adjustment of Standardized Mortality/Hospitalization Ratio (SMR/SHR) models used in public reporting of dialysis quality of care, such as the Annual Dialysis Facility Report.

Study design: Retrospective observational study.

Setting & participants: 625,040 US maintenance dialysis patients with >90 kidney failure days in 2019.

Predictors: Nursing home status variables; patient characteristics; comorbid conditions.

Outcomes: Mortality/hospitalization.

Analytical approach: We assigned patients and patient times (SMR/SHR model) to one of 3 mutually exclusive categories: long-term care (≥90 days), short-term care (1-89 days), or non-nursing home, based on nursing home stay during the previous 365 days from the first day of the time period at risk. Nursing home status was derived from the Nursing Home Minimum Data Set. Comparisons of hazard ratios from adjusted models, facility SMR/SHR performance, and model C-statistics between the original/new models were performed.

Results: SMR's hazard ratio of original nursing home status (2.09) was lower than both ratios of short-term care (2.38) and long-term care (2.43), whereas SHR's hazard ratio of original nursing home status (1.10) was between the ratios of long-term care (1.01) and short-term care (1.20). There was a difference in hazard ratios between short-term care and long-term care for both measures. Small percentages of facilities changed performance categories: 0.7% for SMR and 0.4% for SHR. The SMR C-statistic improved whereas the SHR C-statistic was relatively unchanged.

Limitations: Limited capture of subacute rehabilitation stays in the nursing home by using a 90-day cutoff for short-term care and long-term care; unable to draw causal inference about nursing home care.

Conclusions: Use of a nursing home metric that effectively separates short-term from long-term nursing home utilization results in more meaningful risk adjustment that generally comports with Medicare payment policy, potentially resulting in more interpretable results for dialysis stakeholders.

Keywords: End stage kidney disease; kidney failure; nursing home status; standardized mortality/hospitalization ratio.