Gut bacterial metabolism of dietary flavonoids results in the production of a variety of phenolic acids, whose contributions to health remain poorly understood. Here, we show that supplementation with the commonly consumed flavonoid quercetin impacted gut microbiome composition and resulted in a significant reduction in atherosclerosis burden in conventionally-raised (ConvR) Apolipoprotein E (ApoE) knockout (KO) mice fed a high-MAC (microbiota-accessible carbohydrates) diet. However, this effect was not observed in animals consuming a defined diet containing low levels of MAC. Furthermore, we found that the effect of quercetin on atherosclerosis required gut microbes, as supplementation of this flavonoid to germ-free (GF) ApoE KO mice consuming the high-MAC diet did not affect the development of atherosclerosis. Metabolomic analysis revealed that consumption of quercetin significantly increased plasma levels of benzoylglutamic acid and protocatechuic acid in ConvR mice exposed to the high-MAC diet, while these increases were not observed in GF mice or conventional animals consuming the low-MAC diet supplemented with the flavonoid. Furthermore, levels of these metabolites were negatively associated with atherosclerosis burden. Altogether, these results suggest that the beneficial effects of quercetin on atherosclerosis are influenced by gut microbes and dietary MAC.