Different threats posed by two major mobilized colistin resistance genes - mcr-1.1 and mcr-3.1 - revealed through comparative genomic analysis

Abstract

Objectives: Global spread of mobilized colistin resistance gene (mcr)-carrying Escherichia coli poses serious threats to public health. This study aimed to provide insights into different threats posed by two major mcr variants: mcr-1.1 and mcr-3.1.

Methods: Genetic backgrounds and characteristics of mobile genetic elements carrying mcr-1.1 or mcr-3.1 in 74 (mcr)-carrying E. coli isolated from swine farms were analysed, and comparative genomic analysis was performed with the public sequence database.

Results: The mcr-1.1 showed high horizontal transferability (6.30 logCFU/ml). Genetic background of mcr-1.1, including genetic cassette/plasmid, was transferred without insertion sequences (ISs) and/or multi-drug resistance (MDR) and highly shared across strains. The major mcr-1.1-cassette was "mcr-1.1-pap2", mainly encoded in IncI2 and IncX4. Mcr-3.1 exhibited relatively lower conjugation frequency (0.97 logCFU/ml). The mcr-3.1-cassette was flanked by IS26 and was highly variable across strains because of the insertion, deletion, or truncation of IS6100, IS4321, or IS5075. Near the mcr-3.1 cassette, MDR regions consisting of antimicrobial/heavy metal resistance genes were identified, which varied across strains. From the MCR3-E13 strain, a mcr-3.1-carrying IncHI2-fragment was integrated into the bacterial chromosome via IS26-mediated co-integration. To our knowledge, this was the first study to describe that a mcr-3.1-carrying plasmid could be inserted into the bacterial chromosome.

Conclusions: Based on high horizontal transferability, mcr-1.1 could play a major role on colistin resistance propagation. On the other hand, mcr-3.1 could be transmitted with MDR and have dual pathways mediated by plasmid transfer (horizontal transmission) and chromosomal insertion (vertical transmission), enabling it to proliferate stably despite its lower horizontal transferability.

Keywords: Colistin; Horizontal transfer; Mobile genetic elements; Multidrug resistance; mcr-1.1-cassette; mcr-3.1-cassette.