Reciprocal Donor-Recipient Strain Combinations Present Different Vascularized Composite Allotransplantation Outcomes in Rodent Models

Abstract

Background: Although vascularized composite allotransplantation (VCA) has been the focus of many animal studies, further research is needed to determine the potential for a generalized model and immunosuppression regimen that applies across different donor-recipient combinations. In this study, the authors evaluated the outcome of VCAs performed on reciprocal rodent donor-recipient combinations.

Methods: VCA was performed in rats using Lewis and Brown Norway (BN) donor-recipient pairs, under the previously reported antilymphocyte serum/cyclosporine/adipose-derived stem cell regimen. Similarly, a published co-stimulatory blockade/rapamycin regimen was performed on the mouse VCA model between Balb/C and C57BL/6 strains.

Results: To accommodate the active behaviors of BN recipients, the allograft had to be modified and inset to the neck instead of to the groin. The tolerogenic regimen did not provide the same benefits for BN rats as it did for Lewis recipients. Increasing antilymphocyte serum dose and extending the duration of cyclosporine administration from 10 to 21 days significantly prolonged allograft survival and induced donor-specific tolerance. In mice, the co-stimulatory blockade/rapamycin regimen produced inferior VCA outcomes in BALB/c recipients than in C57BL/6 recipients. In both rats and mice, the authors identified an association between the tolerance outcome and the peripheral chimerism measured on postoperative day 30.

Conclusions: Reciprocal donor-recipient combinations led to different responses toward the immunosuppression regimen and varied VCA outcomes. Sustained donor chimerism that remained in circulation for 1 month after surgery supported long-term VCA survival. Modification of the model and immunosuppression regimen accordingly is recommended.

Clinical relevance statement: Various donor-recipient combinations respond differently to the immunosuppression regimens. Maintaining donor chimerism for 30 days after surgery improves VCA survival. It is recommended to tailor the immunosuppression regimen based on the recipient's background to optimize outcomes.