The electronic structure of copper corroles has been a topic of debate and revision since the advent of corrole chemistry. The ground state of these compounds is best described as an antiferromagnetically coupled Cu(II) corrole radical cation. In coordinating solvents, these molecules become paramagnetic, and this is often accompanied by a color change. The underlying chemistry of these solvent-induced properties is currently unknown. Here, we show that a coordinating solvent, such as pyridine, induces a change in the ground spin state from an antiferromagnetically coupled Cu(II) corrole radical cation to a ferromagnetically coupled triplet. Over time, the triplet reacts to produce a species with spectral signatures that are characteristic of the one-electron-reduced Cu(II) corrole. These observations account for the solvent-induced paramagnetism and the associated color changes that have been observed for copper corroles in coordinating solvents.