Dose-dependent joint resistance action of antibacterial mixtures in their hormetic effects on bacterial resistance based on concentration addition model

Abstract

The judgment of joint resistance action is significant for evaluating the resistance risk of antibacterial mixture. Using bacterial mutation frequency (MF) and conjugative transfer frequency (CTF) to respectively characterize the bacterial endogenous and exogenous resistance, mutation unit and conjugative transfer unit have been proposed to judge the joint resistance action of antibacterial mixture at a certain dose. However, these methods could not evaluate the antibacterial mixture's joint resistance action at a larger concentration-range. In this study, the concentration addition for bacterial resistance (CA-BR) approach was used to judge the joint resistance actions between kanamycin sulfate (KAN) and some other typical antibacterial agents, including sulfonamides (SAs), sulfonamide potentiators (SAPs), and silver antibacterial compounds (SACs). Through comparing the hormetic dose-response curves of the binary mixtures on the MF (or CTF) in Escherichia coli (E. coli) and the corresponding CA-BR curves calculated from the hormetic dose-responses of the single agents, the joint resistance actions between KAN and other agents were judged to exhibit dose-dependent feature: with the increase of mixture concentration, the joint mutation actions between KAN and SAs (or SAPs) were fixed at synergism, and the joint mutation actions between KAN and SACs varied from antagonism to synergism; the joint conjugative transfer actions between KAN and other agents changed from antagonism to synergism. Mechanistic explanation suggested that the heterogeneous pattern of joint resistance action had a close relationship with the interplays among the agents' modes of action, and meanwhile was significantly influenced by their joint survival pressure on E. coli. This study reveals the dose-dependent feature for the joint resistance action of antibacterial mixture and highlights the importance of exposure concentration, which will benefit clarifying the resistance risk of antibacterial mixture in the environment.

Keywords: Antibacterial mixture; Bacterial resistance; Concentration addition; Dose-dependent; Hormetic effects; Joint resistance action.