Conventional quantum mechanical-molecular mechanics (QM/MM) simulation approaches for modeling enzyme reactions often assume that there is one dominant reaction pathway and that this pathway can be sampled starting from an X-ray structure of the enzyme. These assumptions reduce computational cost; however, their validity has not been extensively tested. This is due in part to the lack of a rigorous formalism for integrating disparate pathway information from dynamical QM/MM calculations. Here, we present a way to model ensembles of reaction pathways efficiently using a divide-and-conquer strategy through Hierarchical Markov State Modeling (Hi-MSM). This approach allows information on multiple, distinct pathways to be incorporated into a chemical kinetic model, and it allows us to test these two assumptions. Applying Hi-MSM to the reaction carried out by dihydrofolate reductase (DHFR) we find (i) there are multiple, distinct pathways significantly contributing to the overall flux of the reaction that the conventional approach does not identify and (ii) that the conventional approach does not identify the dominant reaction pathway. Thus, both assumptions underpinning the conventional approach are violated. Since DHFR is a relatively small enzyme, and configuration space scales exponentially with protein size, accounting for multiple reaction pathways is likely to be necessary for most enzymes.