Bright Voice Quality and Fundamental Frequency Variation in Non-binary Speakers

J Voice. 2022 Oct 6:S0892-1997(22)00234-X. doi: 10.1016/j.jvoice.2022.08.001. Online ahead of print.

Abstract

Objectives: 1) To investigate if vocal variation produced by assigned-female-at-birth (AFAB) non-binary people differed from vocal variation produced by cisgender (cis) participants. Cue values produced by non-binary participants were predicted to differ from those values produced by cisgender participants. 2) To determine if previous subjective assessments of bright voice quality in AFAB non-binary participants were quantifiable, and if so, if non-binary and cisgender participants differed in their voice quality production.

Study design: A quantitative comparative research design.

Methods: Phonetic and statistical analyses of continuous speech samples produced by AFAB non-binary and cisgender participants. Vocal cues were mean fundamental frequency (F0) and bright voice quality, measured by cepstral peak prominence-smoothed and spectral slope, with speaker gender as the predictor.

Results: At the group level, non-binary participants produced intermediate F0 values - significantly lower than the cis women's and significantly higher than the cis men's. Individually, the majority of non-binary participants produced mean F0 in this intermediate range. Non-binary participants produced significantly less negative spectral slope and higher cepstral peak prominence-smoothed, indicative of a brighter, more resonant voice quality. Individual-level results indicated that vocal training and vocal tract physiology did not fully account for the results found.

Conclusion: Participants' agency, particularly their motivation to alter vocal output to avoid being misgendered, has an effect on the AFAB non-binary participants' F0 production and potentially their voice quality. The majority of AFAB non-binary participants uniquely produced the cue combination of intermediate F0 and bright voice quality.

Keywords: Cepstral peak prominence-smoothed; Fundamental frequency; Non-binary gender; Spectral slope; Voice quality.