Rainwater harvesting and water balance simulation-optimization scheme to plan sustainable second crop in small rain-fed systems

Abstract

Environmental degradation in the form of water shortage and uncertainty has severely affected the food systems across the globe. Especially in India, which is dominated by rain-fed farmers, the need for sustainable water resource and its management at farm level is imperative for farming livelihoods and food security of the country. Rainwater harvesting in on-farm reservoirs (OFR) can enable crop diversification, year round cropping and seasonal vegetable cultivation in rain-fed farming systems in India. However appropriate sizing of OFR remains a serious concern especially for small and marginal farmers with limited land holdings. In this study, a novel and comprehensive simulation-optimization model was developed to determine the optimal size and utilization of OFR. The simulation consisted of water balance of soil and OFR using hydrological analysis for last 28 years, through which supplement irrigation needs and, rainwater harvesting potential was estimated. Optimal use of available water in OFR was designed using a multi-stage process wherein the model generated, compared and screened appropriate vegetable plans for Rabi cultivation. The model was simulated for different OFR sizes and the optimal size was chosen based on its economic feasibility. To demonstrate the model, a case study was simulated wherein high supplement irrigation was estimated, indicating a severe limitation in rain-fed farming. A minimum OFR size of 9.9% of the total land was required. With an increase in OFR sizes, the profits increased however, the growth rate declined as the cropping area was reduced. An OFR size of 15.5% of total land was found to be optimal which gave benefit-cost ratio and payback period of 2.4 and 6.8 years respectively. Trends in cultivation plans for different sizes of OFR was observed wherein for small OFR sizes, the model generated fewer options of cultivation plans and preferred crops with high water productivity over crops with high profitability. The proposed model is generic and applicable at multiple scales and scenarios. The model could be used by environmental decision makers, farm managers, policy makers and researchers to determine the feasibility of any water resource intervention using an ecosystem centric approach when multiple scenarios of cultivation are possible.

Keywords: Environmental management; On-farm reservoirs; Rainwater harvesting; Simulation-optimization; Sizing; Water management.