The impact of synthesis parameters and structural properties, respectively, on mechanical properties of porous materials on different structural levels provides valuable information for designing materials for specific applications. Within this study, we apply two nonstandard approaches for determining the mechanical properties of the mesoporous backbone phase in a series of disordered SiO2-based monolithic materials possessing hierarchical meso-macroporosity, that is, deformation upon mercury porosimetry and in situ dilatometry during nitrogen adsorption analysis. By using ordered porous model materials, the latter method has been recently proven to provide reliable mechanical moduli. This concept was now applied to a SiO2 monolith developed for high-performance liquid chromatography exhibiting disordered hierarchical meso- and macroporosity, as well as a series of analogue phenyl-modified meso-macroporous SiO2 monoliths with up to 36.1 at% organic modification. The phenyl group was introduced by adding phenyltrimethoxysilane to the sol-gel mixture. The study aimed at investigating in detail the impact of the organic modification on the morphology of the porous solid and the resulting mechanical properties. The study shows that both Hg porosimetry and in situ dilatometry performed during N2 adsorption at 77 K provide similar and reasonable moduli of compression for the mesoporous backbone of the silica materials investigated. These data were compared with moduli of the macroscopic sample as determined from sound velocity measurements by describing the fully connected macroporous backbone with a foam model. The comparison reveals an otherwise overseen side effect of the organic modification of the silica framework: in contrast to the pure reference SiO2 meso-macroporous monoliths, the hybrid material is composed of a more particulate morphology on the mesoscale, that is, mesoporous particles and corresponding necks between them are formed, which results in significant softening of the porous solid on the macroscale.