Performance comparison of homologous and heterologous Newcastle disease virus in vaccines and antibody tests

Abstract

Antigenic differences between commercial Newcastle Disease Virus (NDV) vaccine and circulating field virus reduce vaccine efficacy. Fifty-layer chickens were divided into five groups: three vaccinated chicken groups using killed LaSota (Genotype II/GII), Mega, or VD (Genotype VII/GVII) viral strains, negative, and positive control groups. On day 28, Hemagglutination Inhibition (HI) serology of vaccinated chickens was performed using whole virus antigens of RIVS, LaSota, Mega, and VD strains. Sera were also tested with an alternative antigen, using an ELISA to detect antibody for the cleavage site F protein peptide from GII and GVII NDV strains. Vaccinated and unvaccinated positive control birds underwent infectious challenges using VD and Mega strains. HI testing showed that antibody titers were higher when tested using homologous antigens than heterologous antigens. ELISA performed with alternative antigens did not perform as well as the established HI test using homologous strains. Viral shedding was reduced by vaccination that was homologous to the infectious challenge in comparison with vaccination using the LaSota strain virus. We conclude that superior results are obtained when serological testing, vaccinations, and vaccine challenge experiments all use circulating strains of ND virus. Implementation of this recommendation would likely reduce viral shedding by vaccinated chickens and be more effective in preventing outbreaks of virulent NDV.

Keywords: Fusion protein peptide; Homologous antigen; Homologous vaccine; Newcastle disease virus; Protective titer antibody.