A significant proportion of patients undergoing repair of congenital mitral valve disease will require a subsequent reoperation. During somatic growth, mitral valve repair is preferable to replacement as it allows for annular growth, preservation of ventricular function, and avoidance of lifelong anticoagulation. Techniques to facilitate successful re-repairs for congenital and non-rheumatic mixed degenerative mitral valve disease are not well-described in the literature. Description of the encountered pathology and surgical maneuvers utilized in this case provides real-world tools to help surgeons deal with limited orifice availability, fibrosis, and multilevel lesions. We describe a mitral valve re-repair in a young athlete for a rare cleft posterior mitral leaflet, with a simultaneous tricuspid valve repair and Cox-Maze procedure. We focus on technical pearls that address specific anatomic challenges within our surgical approach.