Treatment of naphthenic acids in oil sands process-affected waters with a surface flow treatment wetland: mass removal, half-life, and toxicity-reduction

Abstract

This study is the first to investigate the removal of naphthenic acids in a full-scale constructed wetland within the Alberta Oil Sands region. The average mass-removal efficiency for all O₂-naphthenic acids measured in three separate deployments in the wetland ranged from 7.5% to 68.9% and appeared sensitive to physicochemical properties of the naphthenic acids, environmental conditions, and water quality. Treatment efficiency of individual naphthenic acids was found to increase with increasing carbon number and decreasing number of double bond equivalents in the molecule. Treatment efficiency was also found to increase with both higher initial turbidity in OSPW entering the wetland, and warmer average OSPW temperatures during wetland operation. Half-life times of naphthenic acids in the treatment wetland ranged between 8.9 and 39 days and were substantially lower than those in tailings ponds (i.e., 12.9-13.6 years) and laboratory studies focussed on bench-scale aerobic microbial biodegradation (i.e., 44-315 days). Using published dose-response data, biomimetic extraction measurements using solid phase microextraction fibers indicate that 14 days of wetland treatment resulted in a reduction in (4 d) deformity of Danio rerio from 50 to 16%, while exhibiting less than 1% toxic response for less sensitive toxic endpoints. The study concludes that wetland treatment is a feasible and productive treatment method for naphthenic acids in oil sands process-affected water due to a combination of sorption and biodegradation.

Keywords: Biomimetic extraction; Naphthenic acids; Oil sands process-affected water; Polar organic chemical integrative samplers; Solid-phase microextraction; Treatment wetlands.