Can images crowdsourced from the internet be used to train generalizable joint dislocation deep learning algorithms?

Abstract

Objective: Deep learning has the potential to automatically triage orthopedic emergencies, such as joint dislocations. However, due to the rarity of these injuries, collecting large numbers of images to train algorithms may be infeasible for many centers. We evaluated if the Internet could be used as a source of images to train convolutional neural networks (CNNs) for joint dislocations that would generalize well to real-world clinical cases.

Methods: We collected datasets from online radiology repositories of 100 radiographs each (50 dislocated, 50 located) for four joints: native shoulder, elbow, hip, and total hip arthroplasty (THA). We trained a variety of CNN binary classifiers using both on-the-fly and static data augmentation to identify the various joint dislocations. The best-performing classifier for each joint was evaluated on an external test set of 100 corresponding radiographs (50 dislocations) from three hospitals. CNN performance was evaluated using area under the ROC curve (AUROC). To determine areas emphasized by the CNN for decision-making, class activation map (CAM) heatmaps were generated for test images.

Results: The best-performing CNNs for elbow, hip, shoulder, and THA dislocation achieved high AUROCs on both internal and external test sets (internal/external AUC): elbow (1.0/0.998), hip (0.993/0.880), shoulder (1.0/0.993), THA (1.0/0.950). Heatmaps demonstrated appropriate emphasis of joints for both located and dislocated joints.

Conclusion: With modest numbers of images, radiographs from the Internet can be used to train clinically-generalizable CNNs for joint dislocations. Given the rarity of joint dislocations at many centers, online repositories may be a viable source for CNN-training data.

Keywords: Arthroplasty; Artificial intelligence; Deep learning; Joint dislocations.