Motion and Strength Analysis of 2-Tine Staple and K-Wire Fixation in Scapholunate Ligament Stabilization in a Cadaver Model

Daniel Hess; Anthony Archual; Zachary Burnett; Hans Prakash; Emily Dooley; Shawn Russell; Aaron Freilich; A Rashard Dacus

doi:10.1016/j.jhsg.2020.12.004

Motion and Strength Analysis of 2-Tine Staple and K-Wire Fixation in Scapholunate Ligament Stabilization in a Cadaver Model

J Hand Surg Glob Online. 2021 Feb 6;3(2):67-73. doi: 10.1016/j.jhsg.2020.12.004. eCollection 2021 Mar.

Authors

Daniel Hess¹, Anthony Archual¹, Zachary Burnett¹, Hans Prakash², Emily Dooley³, Shawn Russell³, Aaron Freilich¹, A Rashard Dacus¹

Affiliations

¹ Department of Orthopaedic Surgery, University of Virginia, Charlottesville, VA.
² School of Medicine, University of Virginia, Charlottesville, VA.
³ University of Virginia Motion Analysis and Motor Performance Lab, Charlottesville, VA.

Abstract

Purpose: Previous studies have demonstrated the benefits of 2- and 4-tine staple fixation in scapholunate interosseous ligament (SLIL) reconstruction, including improved rotational control and avoidance of the articular surface. This study compared scaphoid and lunate kinematics after SLIL fixation with traditional Kirschner wire (K-wire) fixation or 2-tine staple fixation.

Methods: Eight fresh frozen cadaver arms with normal scapholunate (SL) intervals were included. Infrared motion capture was used to assess kinematics between the scaphoid and lunate as the wrists were moved through a simulated dart-throw motion. Kinematic data were recorded for each wrist in 4 states: SLIL intact, SLIL sectioned, K-wire fixation across SL interval and scaphocapitate joint, and 2-tine Nitinol staple fixation across SL interval. Strength of the SL staple fixation was evaluated using an axial load machine to assess load to failure of the staple construct.

Results: Range of motion of the scaphoid and lunate with SLIL intact and SLIL sectioned were similar. K-wire fixation across the SL interval significantly decreased the overall wrist range of motion as well as scaphoid and lunate motion in all planes except for scaphoid flexion. Conversely, scaphoid and lunate motion after staple fixation was similar to that in normal wrists, except for a significant decrease in scaphoid extension. Under axial load simulating a ground-level fall, 3 of 8 arms demonstrated no failure, and none of the failures was due to direct failure of the 2-tine staple.

Conclusions: This study demonstrates 2-tine staple fixation across the SL interval is effective in providing initial stability and maintaining physiologic motion of the scaphoid and lunate compared with K-wire fixation after SLIL injury.

Clinical relevance: This study demonstrates an alternate technique for the stabilization of the SL interval in repair of acute SLIL injuries using 2-tine staple fixation, which maintains near physiologic motion of the scaphoid and lunate after SLIL injury.

Keywords: Carpal motion; SLIL; Scapholunate injury; Staple.