Microbial communities often face external perturbations that can induce lasting changes in their composition and functions. Our understanding of how multispecies communities respond to perturbations such as antibiotics is limited, with susceptibility assays performed on individual, isolated species our primary guide in predicting community transitions. Here, we studied how bacterial growth dynamics can overcome differences in antibiotic susceptibility in determining community resilience: the recovery of the original community state following antibiotic exposure. We used an experimental community containing Corynebacterium ammoniagenes and Lactobacillus plantarum that displays two alternative stable states as a result of mutual inhibition. Although C. ammoniagenes was more susceptible to chloramphenicol in monocultures, we found that chloramphenicol exposure nonetheless led to a transition from the L. plantarum-dominated to the C. ammoniagenes-dominated community state. Combining theory and experiments, we demonstrated that growth rate differences between the two species made the L. plantarum-dominated community less resilient to several antibiotics with different mechanisms of action. Taking advantage of an observed cooperativity—a dependence on population abundance—in the growth of C. ammoniagenes, we next analyzed in silico scenarios that could compromise the high resilience of the C. ammoniagenes-dominated state. The model predicted that lowering the dispersal rate, through interacting with the growth at low population densities, could make the C. ammoniagenes state fragile against virtually any kind of antibiotic, a prediction that we confirmed experimentally. Our results highlight that species susceptibility to antibiotics is often uninformative of community resilience, as growth dynamics in the wake of antibiotic exposure can play a dominant role.
Keywords: alternative stable states; antibiotics; community dynamics; microbial communities; resilience.