Determining the precise limits of life in polyextreme environments is challenging. Studies along gradients of polyextreme conditions in the Dallol proto-volcano area (Danakil salt desert, Ethiopia) showed the occurrence of archaea-dominated communities (up to 99%) in several hypersaline systems but strongly suggested that life did not thrive in the hyperacidic (pH ∼0), hypersaline (∼35% [wt/vol],) and sometimes hot (up to 108°C) ponds of the Dallol dome. However, it was recently claimed that archaea flourish in these brines based on the detection of one Nanohaloarchaeotas 16S rRNA gene and fluorescent in situ hybridization (FISH) experiments with archaea-specific probes. Here, we characterized the diversity of microorganisms in aerosols over Dallol, and we show that, in addition to typical bacteria from soil/dust, they transport halophilic archaea likely originating from neighboring hypersaline ecosystems. We also show that cells and DNA from cultures and natural local halophilic communities are rapidly destroyed upon contact with Dallol brine. Furthermore, we confirm the widespread occurrence of mineral particles, including silica-based biomorphs, in Dallol brines. FISH experiments using appropriate controls show that DNA fluorescent probes and dyes unspecifically bind to mineral precipitates in Dallol brines; cellular morphologies were unambiguously observed only in nearby hypersaline ecosystems. Our results show that airborne cell dispersal and unspecific binding of fluorescent probes are confounding factors likely affecting previous inferences of archaea thriving in Dallol. They highlight the need for controls and the consideration of alternative abiotic explanations before safely drawing conclusions about the presence of life in polyextreme terrestrial or extraterrestrial systems. IMPORTANCE Determining the precise limits of life in polyextreme environments is challenging. Confounding factors such as exogenous contamination and the abiotic formation of structures resembling cells need to be considered before concluding on the unambiguous development of microbial life in low-biomass environments. Here, we explored how these factors can affect contrasting reports about microbial life thriving in the hypersaline and hyperacidic brines of the Dallol geothermal field (Danakil Depression, Ethiopia). We show not only that aerosols actively transport a wide diversity of prokaryotic and eukaryotic cells over Dallol but also that, upon contact with the chaotropic hyperacidic brine, cells and DNA are rapidly degraded. We also show the extant occurrence of mineral (mostly silica-based) biomorphs that unspecifically bind fluorescent probes and dyes. Our study highlights the need for controls and the consideration of alternative abiotic explanations before safely drawing conclusions on the presence of life in polyextreme terrestrial or extraterrestrial systems.
Keywords: archaea; biomorph; biosignature; chaotropic; contaminant; dispersal; extremophile; hydrothermal; hyperacidity; hypersaline; life limits.