Cation-π interactions are the major noncovalent interactions for molecular recognition and play a central role in a broad area of chemistry and biology. Despite tremendous success in understanding the origin and biological importance of cation-π interactions, the design and synthesis of stronger cation-π interactions remain elusive. Here, we report an approach that greatly increases the binding energy of cation-π interactions by replacing Trp in the aromatic box with an electron-rich Trp derivative using the genetic code expansion strategy. The binding affinity between histone H3K4me3 and its reader is increased more than eightfold using genetically encoded 6-methoxy-Trp. Furthermore, through a systematic engineering process, we construct an H3K4me3 Super-Reader with single-digit nM affinity for H3K4me3 detection and imaging. More broadly, this approach paves the way for manipulating cation-π interactions for a variety of applications.