Confucian Role-Ethics with Non-Domination: Civil Compliance in Times of Crisis

Ethical Theory Moral Pract. 2022;25(2):199-213. doi: 10.1007/s10677-022-10282-z. Epub 2022 Mar 22.

Abstract

In this article, combining the Confucian notion of relationality with the republican principle of non-domination, I will shed new light on the ethics of civil compliance in an emergency situation. More specifically, first, by exploring the culturally biased distinctions between individualism and collectivism in the current debates on 'pandemic' nationalism, I will put forward the need for a relationality through which civil cooperation with emergency governance can facilitate the enhancement of both individual freedom and democratic commonality in the long run. Then, by supplementing the moral vision of role-constituted relationality in Confucian role-ethics with the principle of liberty as non-domination in neo-Roman republicanism, I will suggest an ethics of civil compliance which can steer emergency governance toward the consolidation of democratic accountability.

Keywords: Civil compliance; Confucian Role-Ethics; Non-domination; Pandemic nationalism; Relationality.