Phage-based biocontrol is an emerging method for managing the plant pathogen Erwinia amylovora. Control of E. amylovora in North America is achieved chiefly through the application of streptomycin and has led to the development of streptomycin resistance. Resistant E. amylovora can be tracked through the analysis of CRISPR spacer sequences. An alternative to antibiotics are bacterial viruses, known as phages, which lyse their hosts during replication to control the bacterial population. Endogenous CRISPR-Cas systems act as phage resistance mechanisms however, preliminary genomic analysis suggests this activity is limited in E. amylovora. This leaves the functionality of the CRISPR-Cas system, any clade-based differences, and the impact which this system may have on phage-based biocontrol in question. In this study, the CRISPR arrays from 127 newly available genomic sequences of E. amylovora were analyzed through a novel bioinformatic pipeline. Through this, the Eastern and Western North American clades were shown to be incompatible with the current PCR-based approaches for tracking E. amylovora given the size and composition of their CRISPR arrays. Two artificial CRISPR arrays were designed to investigate the functionality of the CRISPR-Cas system in E. amylovora. This system was capable of curing a targeted plasmid and providing phage resistance but was not the source of phage resistance observed within the controls. This suggests that while the CRISPR-Cas system is an important defense mechanism for invasive plasmids, an as yet unidentified mechanism is the primary source of phage resistance in E. amylovora. IMPORTANCE Erwinia amylovora is an economically significant agricultural pathogen found throughout the world. In North America, E. amylovora has developed streptomycin resistance and therefore alternative treatments using phages have received increased attention. In this study, we analyzed recently published genomes to determine that two significant groups of E. amylovora are poorly identified using the current, CRISPR-based tracking methods. We also showed that the CRISPR-Cas system and an unidentified mechanism work together to provide a significant degree of resistance against one of the phages proposed for phage-based biocontrol.
Keywords: CRISPR-Cas; antibiotic resistance; bacteriophage therapy; phage biocontrol; phage resistance; plant pathogens.