Clinical features of adverse events associated with Xiyanping-Ribavirin combination: A systematic review

Abstract

Ethnopharmacological relevance: In China, Xiyanping (XYP) has been widely used in combination with Ribavirin (RB) for the treatment of infectious diseases. It has been found that this combination may change the severity of XYP-associated adverse events (AEs).

Aim: To provide a comprehensive review about the clinal features of AEs of XYP-RB combination from randomized controlled trials, cohort studies, case-control studies, case reports, case series, and data from the National Adverse Drug Reaction Monitoring Information System (NADRMIS).

Materials and methods: Seven electronic databases were searched in March 2021. Articles on AEs associated with XYP published from January 2004 to December 2020 in the NADRMIS were included. Data on the incidence of AEs, distribution of AEs, occurrence time of AEs, type and possible signal of AEs, primary diseases, allergic history, family history of allergies, dosage, and combination interval were extracted.

Results: We included 228 cases of AEs with XYP-RB combination (63 cases from randomized controlled trials, 1 from a cohort study, and 164 from the NADRMIS). The most common primary disease was hand-foot-and-mouth disease. The main age distribution was 0-6 years (118 cases, 72%) and 8 cases (6.8%) experienced serious AEs. The combination group showed a significant reduction than the RB group in the incidence of AEs in those with hand-foot-and-mouth disease (risk ratio = 0.54, 95% confidence interval = 0.38-0.78, P = 0.0008) and children with viral pneumonia (risk ratio = 0.36, 95% confidence interval = 0.14-0.95, P = 0.04). Allergic history and infusion interval were not described in the randomized controlled trials. AEs were reported in 57.9% of cases in the first combination (XYP-RB were combined for the first time) (NADRMIS), 56.4% of which were skin and appendage reactions, and the risk signal of skin and appendage reactions was a maximum (Information Component = 6.21).

Conclusion: The major AE associated with XYP-RB combination was skin and appendage reactions. Most of the combination AEs were pseudo-allergic reactions. These findings suggest that we should increase awareness about the safety of XYP-RB combination treatment and standardize medication protocol, especially for children. Unless absolutely necessary, children should avoid combination therapy. More rigorous high-quality studies are needed to obtain more evidence.

Keywords: Adverse drug reaction; Herb-drug combination; Pseudo-allergic reaction; Ribavirin; Systematic review; Xiyanping.