Effect of airborne-particle abrasion with a novel spherical abrasive on the zirconia surface

Abstract

Statement of problem: A novel zirconia-alumina composite (ZAC) particle has yet to be studied for airborne-particle abrasion in a bonding protocol for the zirconia surface.

Purpose: The purpose of this in vitro study was to evaluate the shear bond force of resin cement to yttria-stabilized tetragonal zirconia polycrystal (Y-TZP) when using spherical ZAC particles to conduct airborne-particle abrasion and modify the topography of Y-TZP.

Material and methods: Spherical 30- to 70-μm ZAC particles were fabricated by using a hybrid gel technique. A total of 160 Ø6.6×4.0-mm zirconia disks were fabricated from 4 commercially available zirconia blanks, e.max ZirCAD zirconia (EM), NexxZr T zirconia (NE), Lava Plus High Translucency zirconia (LP), and Imagine High Translucency Zirconia (IM), by using computer-aided manufacturing technology. As-sintered specimens without further surface treatment were used as controls (ZR0). Surface treatment groups included sharp-edged alumina airborne-particle abrasion (ABC), 50 μm, 0.2 MPa; airborne-particle abrasion with ZAC particle at 0.2 MPa (2ZA); and airborne-particle abrasion with spherical ZAC particle at 0.4 MPa (4ZA). All surface treatment groups were airborne-particle abraded at the specified pressures for 10 seconds at a standardized distance of 10 mm. The surface roughness (Ra) and area roughness (Sa) of specimens from each group were measured. Following the application of an adhesive (Scotchbond Universal), Ø6.6×4.0-mm resin cement (RelyX Ultimate) buttons were fabricated for shear bond testing by using a universal testing machine at a 5-mm/min crosshead speed (n=10). The data were analyzed by using a 2-way ANOVA, Tukey HSD test, and regression analysis (α=0.05). Scanning electron microscopy (SEM) was performed to observe changes of the zirconia surface and the failure modes of each group before and after shear bond testing.

Results: The mean ±standard deviation shear bond force values ranged from 272.6 ±41.4 N to 686.7 ±152.8 N. Statistically significant higher force values than those of the controls (P<.05) were obtained by using airborne-particle abrasion. No significant differences were found among any of the airborne-particle abrasion treatment groups (P>.05). The mean of Ra values ranged from 0.27 μm to 0.74 μm, and the mean of Sa values, from 0.48 μm to 1.48 μm. SEM observation revealed that the zirconia surface was made jagged by abrasion with sharp-edged alumina particles. The spherical ZAC particles create microcraters on the zirconia surface. Fractographic observation disclosed that failures were adhesive-cohesive failure modes with residual resin cement attached on the zirconia surface.

Conclusions: The surface treatment of zirconia with sharp-edged alumina or the spherical ZAC abrasives improved the bonding force between the zirconia and resin cement. No statistically significant differences in shear bond force values were found between airborne-particle abrasion surface treatment groups.