Catechol reaction mechanisms form the basis of marine mussel adhesion, allowing for bond formation and cross-linking in wet saline environments. To mimic mussel foot adhesion and develop new bioadhesive underwater glues, it is essential to understand and learn to control their redox activity as well as their chemical reactivity. Here, we study the electrochemical characteristics of functionalized catechols to further understand their reaction mechanisms and find a stable and controllable molecule that we subsequently integrate into a polymer to form a highly adhesive hydrogel. Contradictory to previous hypotheses, 3,4-dihydroxy-L-phenylalanine is shown to follow a Schiff-base reaction whereas dopamine shows an intramolecular ring formation. Dihydrocaffeic acid proved to be stable and was substituted onto a poly(allylamine) backbone and electrochemically cross-linked to form an adhesive hydrogel that was tested using a surface forces apparatus. The hydrogel's compression and dehydration dependent adhesive strength have proven to be higher than in mussel foot proteins (mfp-3 and mfp-5). Controlling catechol reaction mechanisms and integrating them into stable electrochemically depositable macroscopic structures is an important step in designing new biological coatings and underwater and biomedical adhesives.