δ15N of Chironomidae: An index of nitrogen sources and processing within watersheds for national aquatic monitoring programs

Abstract

Nitrogen (N) removal along flowpaths to aquatic ecosystems is an important regulating ecosystem service that can help reduce N pollution in the nation's waterways, but can be challenging to measure at large spatial scales. Measurements that integrate N processing within watersheds would be particularly useful for assessing the magnitude of this vital service. Because most N removal processes cause isotopic fractionation, δ¹⁵N from basal food-chain organisms in aquatic ecosystems can provide information on both N sources and the degree of watershed N processing. As part of EPA's National Aquatic Resource Surveys (NARS), we measured δ¹⁵N of Chironomidae collected from over 2000 lakes, rivers and streams across the continental USA. Using information on N inputs to watersheds and summer total N concentrations ([TN]) in the water column, we assessed where elevated chironomid δ¹⁵N would indicate N removal rather than possible enriched sources of N. Chironomid δ¹⁵N values ranged from -4 to +20‰, and were higher in rivers and streams than in lakes, indicating that N in rivers and streams underwent more processing and cycling that preferentially removes ¹⁴N than N in lakes. Chironomid δ¹⁵N increased with watershed size, N inputs, and water chemical components, and decreased as precipitation increased. In rivers and streams with high watershed N inputs, we found lower [TN] in streams with higher chironomid δ¹⁵N values, suggesting high rates of gaseous N loss such as denitrification. At low watershed N inputs, the pattern reversed; streams with elevated chironomid δ¹⁵N had higher [TN] than streams with lower chironomid δ¹⁵N, possibly indicating unknown sources elevated in δ¹⁵N such as legacy N, or waste from animals or humans. Chironomid δ¹⁵N values can be a valuable tool to assess integrated watershed-level N sources, input rates, and processing for water quality monitoring and assessment at large scales.

Keywords: Lakes; National Aquatic Resource Survey (NARS); Nitrogen isotopes; Nitrogen processing; Rivers and streams; Water quality.