A Bayesian Nonparametric Approach for Modeling SF-6D Health State Utility Scores

Abstract

Objectives: Typically, models that were used for health state valuation data have been parametric. Recently, many researchers have explored the use of nonparametric Bayesian methods in this field. In this article, we report on the results from using a nonparametric model to predict a Bayesian short-form 6-dimension (SF-6D) health state valuation algorithm along with estimating the effect of the individual characteristics on health state valuations.

Methods: A sample of 126 Lebanese members from the American University of Beirut valued 49 SF-6D health states using the standard gamble technique. Results from applying the nonparametric model were reported and compared with those obtained using a standard parametric model. The covariates' effect on health state valuations was also reported.

Results: The nonparametric Bayesian model was found to perform better than the parametric model at (1) predicting health state values within the full estimation data and in an out-of-sample validation in terms of mean predictions, root mean squared error, and the patterns of standardized residuals and (2) allowing for the covariates' effect to vary by health state. The findings also suggest a potential age effect with some gender effect.

Conclusions: The nonparametric model is theoretically more flexible and produces better utility predictions from the SF-6D than previously used classical parametric model. In addition, the Bayesian model is more appropriate to account the covariates' effect. Further research is encouraged.

Keywords: SF-6D; covariates; nonparametric Bayesian methods; preference-based health measure; standard gamble.