Neuroendocrine tumors (NETs) are a heterogeneous clinical entity with a broad range of grade, pace of disease, functional status, and primary sites. Pathologic classification, diagnostic modalities, and therapeutic options for NETs have evolved considerably in the past decade. In part driven by these advances, incidence and prevalence of NETs are rising in the United States and the practicing oncologist is likely to encounter these in the clinic. However, there are no clear lines of therapy for unresectable or metastatic NETs, and sequencing of systemic therapies depends on consideration of patient and tumor characteristics including extent of disease, grade, pace of growth, functional status, primary site, somatostatin receptor status, performance status, and comorbidities. Familiarity with ongoing clinical trials will guide therapeutic decision making as well. In this review, we seek to provide a framework to formulate and tailor an individualized treatment plan for each patient with a NET.