In sessile organisms, phenotypic plasticity represents an important strategy for dealing with environmental variability. Here we test if phenotypic plasticity enables the common coral Stylophora pistillata to occupy a broad niche. We find clear differences in the photo-physiology of four putative species of photosynthetic dinoflagellate symbionts associated with the coral S. pistillata, namely, Cladocopium 'C35a', 'C79', 'C78a' and 'C8a'. Coral phenotypic responses were also tightly linked to symbiont identity. Corals with Cladocopium 'C8a' have more "open" macro-morphology compared to colonies associating with depth-restricted Cladocopium 'C35a' or 'C78a' in the same shallow water habitat. Corals with Cladocopium 'C8a' had 40 to 60% lower symbiont cell densities compared to other holobionts but were more efficient at acclimating over a range of light levels, with clear mechanisms to dissipate excess light energy. This holobiont contains host-based green fluorescent pigments, increased concentrations of symbiont-based mycosporine amino acids, and xanthophyll cycling in high light habitats. Photosynthetic efficiency was also adjusted over the light habitat. In contrast, limited micro-scale responses were observed between three depth-restricted symbionts: Cladocopium 'C79', 'C35a', and 'C78a'. To optimize light levels reaching the photosynthetic unit, these colonies rely on a more closed macro-morphology under high light levels, which reduces incident light levels by up to 43%, and higher symbiont densities . Our results show that distinct macro- and micro-scale adaptations lead to functional differences between four distinct S. pistillata holobionts, allowing them to co-exist by filling specific niches on a small, but environmentally diverse, spatial scale. Key index words: Light, Symbiodiniaceae, coral, pigments, Stylophora pistillata, ITS2, phenotypic plasticity, niche diversification.
© 2021 Phycological Society of America.