Establishing the state-of-the-art on the adsorption of coexisting pnictogens in water: A literature review

Abstract

The occurrence of pnictogens, namely phosphorus, arsenic, and antimony, can be observed in soils, sediments and mining areas, and their coexistence requires a multifaceted approach to the design of adsorption systems to maximize their simultaneous removal efficiency. Therefore, this work aims to provide an extensive literature review of P, As, and Sb adsorption in multicomponent systems and the statistical treatment of the quantitative results. Binary As-P systems have been the most studied in the literature. The oxidation state did not significantly affect the P influence in As adsorbed amount (p = 0.955), but this influence was correlated with the As:P ratio (p < 0.05). A few works have explored As-Sb and Sb-P systems, demonstrating that effective treatments for As do not always reveal a good removal efficiency of the other pnictogens. The Sb adsorbed amount was significantly less affected in the trivalent than in the pentavalent state in both As-Sb and Sb-P systems (p < 0.05). Most of the interactions were competitive, with a few studies reporting synergistic effects for Sb due to the presence of the other elements. Many topics have been identified as lacking in-depth research: ternary As-Sb-P systems, the effect of concentration ratios, pH, and redox conditions (namely those that lead to trivalent species' prevalence), the surface interactions with materials other than iron oxides, and the influence of other aqueous components. This review provides a first step in gathering the relevant literature and approaching the study of adsorption treatment methodology as a complex subject involving many factors.

Keywords: Adsorption; Antimony; Arsenic; Competition; Multicomponent; Phosphorus.