The thermal unimolecular decomposition of a methoxy radical (CH3O), a key intermediate in the combustion of methane, methanol, and other hydrocarbons, was studied using high-level coupled-cluster calculations, followed by E,J-resolved master equation analyses. The experimental results available for a wide range of temperature and pressure are in striking agreement with the calculations. In line with a previous theoretical study that used a one-dimensional master equation, the tunneling correction is found to exhibit a marked pressure dependence, being the largest at low pressure. This curious effect on the tunneling enhancement also affects the calculated kinetic isotope effect, which falls initially with pressure but is predicted to rise again at high pressures. These findings serve to reconcile a set of conflicting results regarding the importance of tunneling in this prototype unimolecular reaction and also motivate further experimental investigation. This study also exemplifies how changes in the energy redistribution due to collisions manifest in the tunneling rates.