Robustness against point mutations of genetic code extensions under consideration of wobble-like effects

Abstract

Many theories of the evolution of the genetic code assume that the genetic code has always evolved in the direction of increasing the supply of amino acids to be encoded (Barbieri, 2019; Di Giulio, 2005; Wong, 1975). In order to reduce the risk of the formation of a non-functional protein due to point mutations, nature is said to have built in control mechanisms. Using graph theory the authors have investigated in Blazej et al. (2019) if this robustness is optimal in the sense that a different codon-amino acid assignment would not generate a code that is even more robust. At present, efforts to expand the genetic code are very relevant in biotechnological applications, for example, for the synthesis of new drugs (Anderson et al., 2004; Chin, 2017; Dien et al., 2018; Kimoto et al., 2009; Neumann et al., 2010). In this paper we generalize the approach proposed in Blazej et al. (2019) and will explore hypothetical extensions of the standard genetic code with respect to their optimal robustness in two ways: (1) We keep the usual genetic alphabet but move from codons to longer words, such as tetranucleotides. This increases the supply of coding words and thus makes it possible to encode non-canonical amino acids. (2) We expand the genetic alphabet by introducing non-canonical base pairs. In addition, the approach from Blazej et al. (2019) and Blazej et al. (2018) is extended by incorporating the weights of single point-mutations into the model. The weights can be interpreted as probabilities (appropriately normalized) or degrees of severity of a single point mutation. In particular, this new approach allows us to take a closer look at the wobble effects in the translation of codons into amino acids. According to the results from Blazej et al. (2019) and Blazej et al. (2018), the standard genetic code is not optimal in terms of its robustness to point mutations if the weights of single point mutations are not taken into account. After incorporation into the model weights that mimic the wobble effect, the results of the present work show that it is much more robust, almost optimal in that respect. We hope, that this theoretical analysis might help to assess extended genetic codes and their abilities to encode new amino acids.

Keywords: Genetic code; Point mutations; Wobble-effect.