Interest in the response of highly reflecting objects in water to modulated acoustical radiation forces makes it appropriate to consider contributions to such forces from perfectly reflecting objects to provide insight into radiation forces. The acoustic illumination can have wavelengths much smaller than the object's size, and objects of interest may have complicated shapes. Here, the specular contribution to the oscillating radiation force on an infinite circular cylinder at normal incidence is considered for double-sideband-suppressed carrier-modulated acoustic illumination. The oscillatory magnitude of the specular force decreases monotonically with increasing modulation frequency, and the phase of the oscillating force depends on the relative phase of the sidebands. The phase dependence on the modulation frequency can be reduced with the appropriate selection of a sideband relative-phase parameter. That is a consequence of the significance of rays that are incident on the cylinder having small impact parameters that are nearly backscattered. For one choice of a relative sideband phase, a prior partial wave series (PWS) solution is available, which supports the specular analysis when the PWS is evaluated for a rigid cylinder. The importance of specular contributions for aluminum cylinders in water is noted. A specular analysis for an analogous spherical reflector is also summarized.