Soil and water conservation management on hill slopes in southwest Ethiopia. II. Modeling effects of soil bunds on surface runoff and maize yield using AquaCrop

Abstract

On the cultivated slopes of the highlands of southwest Ethiopia, soil degradation due to water erosion is a challenge for crop production. To limit surface runoff and soil erosion, soil bunds often in combination with trenches, constructed along contour lines, are common. In addition to the interception of surface runoff, soil bunds may affect crop yield. Here, we evaluate effect of soil bunds on surface runoff and maize yield, using FAO's AquaCrop model, calibrated based on field experiments in the Bokole-Karetha watershed, in SW Ethiopia. Experiments were conducted in 2018 and 2019 on three neighboring fields, each comprising plots in triplicate without and with soil bunds. Experimental data from 2018 to 2019, which were average and above average with respect to rainfall, indicate that water availability was sufficient or even in excess for maize production. Soil bunds significantly (p < 0.05) reduced surface runoff, but maize yield did not differ significantly. In plots without soil bunds, the AquaCrop model described surface runoff satisfactorily after slight adjustment of the curve number (related to infiltration capacity) in one of the three fields. Maize yields were reproduced adequately after calibrating soil fertility and adjusting water productivity. After calibration and validation, the AquaCrop model was used to hindcast surface runoff and grain yield from 1999 to 2017, given available climatic data for the region. Hindcasts show that maize yield in the Bokole-Karetha watershed, with its relatively high rainfall, is not significantly affected by rainfall in two of the three fields. In the third field maize yield decreases slightly, but significantly (p < 0.05) with rainfall. In the short run, yield differences between plots with and without soil bunds are not significant. However, eventually high surface runoff from plots without soil bunds are expected to result in unsustainable crop production, due to significant erosion and degradation of the often nutrient-poor soils. Implementation of soil and water management techniques, combined with fertilization, are important to prevent soil degradation and nutrient stress on sloping land.

Keywords: Model calibration; Saturated hydraulic conductivity; Soil bunds; Soil fertility level.