Using the endosomal sorting complex required for transport (ESCRT)-III membrane remodeling complex as an example, we analyze three popular coarse-grained models (the regular MARTINI, polarizable MARTINI (POL-MARTINI), and big multipole water MARTINI (BMW-MARTINI)) for the description of membrane curvature sensing and generation activities of peripheral proteins. Although the three variants of the MARTINI model provide consistent descriptions for the protein-protein interface in a linear filament model of ESCRT-III, they differ considerably in terms of protein-membrane interface and therefore membrane curvature sensing and generation behaviors. In particular, BMW-MARTINI provides the most consistent description of the protein-membrane interface as compared to all-atom simulations, whereas the regular MARTINI is most consistent with atomistic simulations in terms of the qualitative sign of membrane curvature sensing and generation. With POL-MARTINI, the ESCRT-III model interacts weakly with the membrane and therefore does not exhibit any curvature-sensitive activities. Analysis suggests that the incorrect membrane curvature activities predicted by BMW-MARTINI are due to overestimated insertion depth of an amphipathic helix and incorrect sign for the spontaneous curvature of anionic lipids. These results not only point to ways that coarse-grained models can be improved but also explicitly highlight local lipid composition and insertion depth of protein motifs as essential regulatory factors for membrane curvature sensing and generation.
Copyright © 2021 Biophysical Society. Published by Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved.