The Best of Both Worlds: Eliminating Creatine Kinase-Muscle/Brain (CK-MB) Testing in the Emergency Department Leads to Lower Costs Without Missed Clinical Diagnoses

Abstract

The 2014 American Heart Association/American College of Cardiology (AHA/ACC) clinical guidelines recommend cardiac troponin as a superior biomarker to creatine kinase (CK) and creatine kinase-muscle/brain (CK-MB) for the detection of acute coronary syndrome (ACS), namely myocardial infarction and unstable angina. In April 2018, our Emergency Department (ED) transitioned from using standard troponin to using high-sensitivity troponin T, and adopted a clinical guideline consistent with the AHA/ACC. The guideline recommended high-sensitivity troponin T without CK/CK-MB testing in the majority of clinical situations, limiting CK/CK-MB testing to two specific clinical cases: 1) estimated glomerular filtration rate (eGFR) value <15 mL/min, or 2) recent acute coronary syndrome (ACS) event. Per our ED's policy, a "negative" troponin T was defined as being below the limit of detection (LOD) (i.e., <6 ng/L); such a value obtained at least 3 hours after symptom onset "ruled out" an ACS event and did not require a repeat troponin. The goal of this retrospective study was to determine whether the guideline limiting CK-MB testing missed clinically-significant cardiac outcomes (ACS or new diagnosis of coronary artery disease [CAD]) or was associated with mortality. Pre-implementation data (July 1, 2017 - December 31, 2017) was compared with post-implementation data (July 1, 2018 - December 31, 2018). After guideline introduction, CK/CK-MB ordering decreased by nearly 90%, while troponin ordering increased by nearly 20%, likely due to the introduction in June 2018 of high-sensitivity troponin T, which yielded numerous intermediate/indeterminate-range results that prompted repeat testing. Fewer than 1.5% of patients with a "negative" troponin (below the LOD) and a "positive" CK-MB (above the upper limit of normal [ULN]) had ACS or new-diagnosis CAD; patients with either diagnosis did not expire during their hospital stay or within 30 days of their index visit. CK-MB Index, which has a higher specificity than CK, only found ACS or new CAD among 0.8% of positive results. Considering both decreased CK/CK-MB and increased troponin ordering, the net annual direct cost savings in cardiac biomarker testing was extrapolated to $12,700. Had our institution not transitioned to higher cost high-sensitivity troponin ($2.054/unit) from standard troponin ($1.65/unit), and had the rate of troponin ordering increased solely proportionate to the rate of ED visit increase (2% year-over-year) rather than increase nearly 20% (likely due to the transition to high-sensitivity troponin), then the total six-month direct costs on troponin testing would have been $14,632 instead of $21,267.12, and annual direct cost savings would have been $18,945.80 instead of $12,700. The new ED clinical guideline did not result in a significant number of missed ACS or new-diagnosis CAD, and was associated with direct cost savings. These savings probably underestimate total savings, as the reduced number of "false-positive" CK-MB results likely prevented additional costs, such as hospitalization, specialty consultation, coronary calcium CT, echocardiogram, cardiac stress test, and coronary artery catheterization.

Keywords: acute coronary syndrome; cardiac troponin; ck-mb; creatine kinase; myocardial infarction; troponin; unstable angina.