Power and Efficacy of Maternal Voice in Neonatal Intensive Care Units: Implicit Bias and Family-Centered Care

Abstract

Introduction: Implicit bias can lead medical professionals in Neonatal Intensive Care Units (NICUs) to disregard mothers who are Black and economically disadvantaged as they advocate for their infants' health. Disregard can weaken underlying communication principles within the Family-Centered Care (FCC) model of pediatric health in NICUs and increase maternal distress. This study is the first to address communication disregard by examining mothers' perceived power and efficacy of voice with NICU doctors and nurses. We hypothesized that mothers who are Black and economically disadvantaged would report lower efficacy of voice and higher levels of distress as compared to White mothers with higher income.

Methods: During pre-assessment within a small clinical trial of a parenting intervention, 33 racially and economically diverse mothers, from three Midwest NICUs serving the urban poor, responded to a 14-item measure of maternal power and efficacy of voice and measures of somatization, depression, anxiety and eating/sleeping disorders. Nonparametric examinations assessed the relation of power and efficacy of voice to maternal race, income, and distress.

Results: In contrast to White, higher-income mothers, Black, economically disadvantaged mothers reported lower perceived efficacy of voice with doctors (U = 74.5, d = 0.65) and nurses (U = 74.0; d = .0.66). These mothers with lower perceived efficacy with doctors and nurses, reported higher levels of somatization (U = 16.5, d = 1.14; U = 13.5, d = 1.38, respectively) and eating disorders (U = 14.0, d = 1.29; U = 12.0, d = 1.48, respectively).

Discussion: Study results are discussed within the framework of implicit bias in FCC in the NICU, expanding our understanding of effective communication with economically stressed, Black mothers.

Keywords: Family-Centered Care; Implicit bias; Maternal distress; NICU.