Objective rapid eye movement sleep characteristics of recurrent isolated sleep paralysis: a case-control study

Abstract

Study objectives: Recurrent isolated sleep paralysis (RISP) is a rapid eye movement (REM) parasomnia characterized by a dissociative state with characteristics of REM sleep and wakefulness. Pathophysiology has not yet been clarified and very little research has been performed using objective polysomnographic measures with inconsistent results. The main aim of our study was to find whether higher REM sleep fragmentation is consistent with the theory of state dissociation or whether signs of dissociation can be detected by spectral analysis.

Methods: A total of 19 participants in the RISP group and 19 age- and gender-matched participants in the control group underwent two consecutive full-night video-polysomnography recordings with 19-channel electroencephalography. Apart from sleep macrostructure, other REM sleep characteristics such as REM sleep arousal index, percentage of wakefulness and stage shifts within REM sleep period were analyzed, as well as power spectral analysis during REM sleep.

Results: No difference was found in the macrostructural parameters of REM sleep (percentage of REM sleep and REM latency). Similarly, no significant difference was detected in REM sleep fragmentation (assessed by REM sleep arousal index, percentage of wakefulness and stage shifts within REM sleep). Power spectral analysis showed higher bifrontal beta activity in the RISP group during REM sleep.

Conclusions: The results showed an underlying persistent trait of higher cortical activity that may predispose patients with sleep paralysis to be more likely to experience recurrent episodes, without any apparent macrostructural features including higher REM sleep fragmentation.

Keywords: REM fragmentation; REM pathophysiology; REM sleep; REM sleep arousal index; polysomnography; power spectral analysis; recurrent isolated sleep paralysis.