The mechanism by which acid zeolites catalyze the formation of aromatic species is not fully understood and is important in an array of industrial processes such as the methanol to gasoline reaction. The so-called "carbon pool" mechanism is generally agreed to be the main channel for the formation of hydrocarbons from methanol. There is, however, no agreed sequence of elementary steps that explains how linear intermediates transform to cyclic intermediates, let alone aromatic rings. Recent work suggests the formation of conjugated trienes during zeolite-catalyzed aromatization, but mechanisms involving triene-derived carbocations have never been investigated using modern computational tools. In this work, we propose a new mechanism for cyclization of hexatriene over the Brønsted acid site of faujasite zeolite. Microkinetic models (MKM) using the results of Density Functional Theory (DFT) calculations predict selectivity for neutral 5-membered-ring intermediates over 6-membered-ring intermediates, as suggested by infrared and UV-vis spectroscopic results reported by others. Given that the products of aromatization are 6-membered rings, this result suggests that triene cyclization can only explain how linear hydrocarbons become cyclic intermediates but not the mechanisms that ultimately lead to the aromatic rings seen in industrial zeolite-catalyzed hydrocarbon processes.