Preferential uptake of either levorotatory (L) or dextrorotatory (D) enantiomer of a chiral molecule is a potential planetary life-detection method. On Earth, bacteria, as a rule, metabolize D-sugars and L-amino acids. Here, we use growth experiments to identify exceptions to the rule and their potential impact on the method's reliability. Our experiments involve six strains of Bacillus and collective uptake of the sugars glucose and arabinose, and the amino acids alanine, glutamic acid, leucine, cysteine, and serine-all of which are highly soluble. We find that selective uptake is not evident unless (1) each sugar is tested individually and (2) multiple amino acids are tested together in a mixture. Combining sugars should be avoided because, as we show in Bacillus bacteria, the same organisms may catabolize one sugar, glucose, in D-form and another sugar, arabinose, in L-form. Single amino acids should be avoided because bacteria can access certain proteinogenically incompatible enantiomers using specific racemases. Specifically, bacteria contain an alanine acid racemase and can catabolize D-alanine if no other D-amino acids are present. The proposed improvements would reliably separate nonselective chemical reactions from biological reactions and, if life is indicated, inform whether the selective patterns for amino acids and sugars are the same as on Earth.
Keywords: Atacama Desert; Bacillus; Chirality; Life detection; Metabolism.