Does continuous straw returning keep China farmland soil organic carbon continued increase? A meta-analysis

Abstract

The straw returning technique is one of the important measures for soil carbon sequestration and soil organic carbon (SOC) promotion in the world. However, the patterns of straw utilization in China with various methods among regions, the effect and variability of straw returning on SOC in different areas of China remain uncertain. We conducted a meta-analysis of 446 sets of data from 95 studies in China field to explore how the environmental factors and field management affect SOC after straw returning. The results showed that straw returning to the field significantly increase SOC content by an average of 13.97% (n = 446). The SOC increased effects are more obvious under areas with mean annual precipitation (MAP) > 500 mm, temperature (MAT) > 10 °C, loam or sandy soil, or the initial SOC content <10 g kg^-1. The effect of straw returning on SOC also depends on planting systems, ranging from 5.43% of rice continuous cropping to 17.05% of the maize-wheat ration. In the rotation system, the SOC increasing effect under paddy-wheat rotation (15.79% in rice and 14.87% in wheat season) was more significant than under wheat-maize rotation (17.05% in wheat and 11.81% in maize season). The proper duration of straw returning is 6-9 years, while it will decrease SOC by 17.06%-20.05% more than 10 years. Moreover, the effects of straw returning under the conditions with deep tillage, the amount of straw more than 9000 kg ha^-1, or combined pure N with 180-240 kg N ha^-1 were better than other methods.

Keywords: Climatic condition; Meta-analysis; Planting systems; Soil organic carbon; Straw returning.