A nonlinear interferometer can be constructed by replacing the beam splitter in the Mach-Zehnder interferometer with four-wave mixing (FWM) process. Meanwhile, the conventional surface plasmon resonance (SPR) sensors can be extensively used to infer the information of refractive index of the sample to be measured via either angle demodulation technique or intensity demodulation technique. Combined with a single FWM process, a quantum SPR sensor has been realized, whose noise floor is reduced below standard quantum limit with sensitivity unobtainable with classical SPR sensor. Therefore, in this work we have theoretically proposed a nonlinear interferometric SPR sensor, in which a conventional SPR sensor is placed inside nonlinear interferometer, which is called as I-type nonlinear interferometric SPR sensor. We demonstrate that near resonance angle I-type nonlinear interferometric SPR sensor has the following advantages: its degree of intensity-difference squeezing, estimation precision ratio, and signal-noise-ratio are improved by the factors of 4.6 dB, 2.3 dB, and 4.6 dB respectively than that obtained with a quantum SPR sensor based on a single FWM process. In addition, the theoretical principle of this work can also be expanded to other types of sensing, such as bending, pressure, and temperature sensors based on a nonlinear interferometer.