Short caregiver interview and play observation for early screening of autism spectrum disorder: Behavior development screening for toddlers (BeDevel)

Abstract

This study validates behavior development screening for toddlers (BeDevel), which utilizes a combination of short caregiver interviews (BeDevel-I) and semistructured play observations (BeDevel-P). The data of 431 toddlers (male 66.2%; mean age (SD) = 29.11 (8.59) months; ASD, n = 201; developmental delay, n = 46; typically developing, n = 184), aged 18 ~ 42 months, were included in the validation of BeDevel. The best clinical estimate diagnosis, screening rate, validity, sensitivity, and reliability of BeDevel were determined based on data cross-sectionally collected using BeDevel and existing diagnostic/screening instruments: autism diagnostic observation schedule (ADOS), autism diagnostic interview (ADI-R), Vineland adaptive behavior scales-II (VABS-II), social response scales (SRS), sequenced language scale for infants (SELSI), Korean childhood autism rating scale (K-CARS), and Korean social communication questionnaire (K-SCQ). The k values of BeDevel-I and BeDevel-P were 0.055 ~ 0.732 and 0.291 ~ 0.752, respectively. Items related to social referencing in BeDevel-P had a particularly high diagnostic validity (k = 0.483 ~ 0.684). Reliabilities of BeDevel-I and BeDevel-P were sufficient (Cronbach's alpha = 0.86 ~ 0.88 and 0.92 ~ 0.95, respectively). BeDevel-I and BeDevel-P showed high sensitivity (BeDevel-I: 85.00 ~ 89.29%; BeDevel-P: 85.00 ~ 91.75%), specificity (BeDevel-I: 77.55 ~ 89.55%; BeDevel-P: 85.09 ~ 97.01%), PPV (BeDevel-I: 70.83 ~ 88.54%; BeDevel-P: 81.52 ~ 94.68%), and NPV (BeDevel-I: 76.00 ~ 95.24%; BeDevel-P: 84.62 ~ 95.45%). The agreement between the composite BeDevel score and ADOS, ADI-R, K-CARS, and K-SCQ was >67.6% (range = 67.6 ~ 90.8%). Combining a short caregiver interview and direct play observation is a valid and reliable screening process. More studies on social referencing as an important early marker are needed. BeDevel can be utilized as a secondary screening instrument before diagnostic confirmation in clinical and community settings. LAY SUMMARY: BeDevel, which consists of a short caregiver interview and direct play observation, is a valid and reliable screening instrument for autism spectrum disorder (ASD). We suggest that BeDevel can be utilized as a secondary instrument before administering diagnostic assessments in clinical and community settings. More studies examining social referencing as a potential behavioral marker of ASD are needed.

Keywords: autism spectrum disorder; early detection; screening; social referencing.