Evaluation of two CAD/CAM materials for Nayyar core and post-retained restorations: Three dimensional stress analysis

Abstract

Objectives: The aim of this study is to assess the stress distribution of a nanoceramic resin CAD/CAM material, Lava Ultimate (LU) and a polymer-infiltrated hybrid ceramic CAD/CAM material, Vita Enamic (VE) for enamel replacement for Nayyar core (corono-radicular dowel and core) or post-retained restoration designs of a maxillary first premolar tooth with missing palatal cusp.

Materials and methods: A three dimensional finite element (FE) modelof maxillary first premolar with two roots was modeled. A mesial-occlusal-distal-palatal (MODP) cavity was designed with cavity floor above cemento-enamel junction and including buccal cuspal reduction. Restoration designs consisted of Nayyar core restoration (NCR) and post-retained restoration (PRR) with a glass fiber post. Vita Enamic (VE), Lava Ultimate (LU) were used for enamel and everX Posterior was used for dentin replacement. Vertical occlusal load (100 N) was applied on a spherical solid rigid material simulating the food stuff. Von Mises (VM) and maximum principle stress values were evaluated separately for the remaining enamel, remaining dentin and restorative material in megapascal (MPa).

Results: The analysis of both VM and maximum principle stress values revealed that the most intense stress accumulation was in the cervical region of enamel for both designs. For VM, similar stress values were observed only in dentin. Stress analysis of restorative materials showed that everX Posterior had the highest stress accumulation.

Conclusions: The comparison of the two techniques showed that PRR had better stress distribution than NCR. NCR or PRR with LU or VE exhibited similar VM stress accumulation in dentin. Maximum principle stress analyses showed that PRR with LU transmitted the least stress to enamel and dentin indicating that when LU is the material of choice, post-retained restoration would be a satisfactory design. VM stress values of enamel revealed that VE absorbed the stress in itself and transferred less stress to dentin. This could point out that for the restoration of maxillary first premolar tooth with missing palatal cusp, VE may be a suitable material for NCR and PRR restoration techniques.

Highlights: When fiber reinforced composite is used as dentin replacement in combination with VE as enamel replacement; any technique; PRR or NCR, may be preferred in the restoration of MODP cavities of endodontically treated maxillary premolars. The clinical relevance has to be further studied in-vivo.

Keywords: CAD/CAM; Endodontically treated teeth; Fiber-reinforced post; Finite element analysis; Resin composite.