How Do Movement Patterns in Weightlifting (Clean) Change When Using Lighter or Heavier Barbell Loads?-A Comparison of Two Principal Component Analysis-Based Approaches to Studying Technique

Abstract

This study compared whole body kinematics of the clean movement when lifting three different loads, implementing two data analysis approaches based on principal component analysis (PCA). Nine weightlifters were equipped with 39 markers and their motion captured with 8 Vicon cameras at 100 Hz. Lifts of 60, 85, and 95% of the one repetition maximum were analyzed. The first PCA (PCA^trial) analyzed variance among time-normed waveforms compiled from subjects and trials; the second PCA (PCA^posture) analyzed postural positions compiled over time, subjects and trials. Load effects were identified through repeated measures ANOVAs with Bonferroni-corrected post-hocs and through Cousineau-Morey confidence intervals. PCA^trial scores differed in the first (p < 0.016, η _p ² = 0.694) and fifth (p < 0.006, η _p ² = 0.768) principal component, suggesting that increased barbell load produced higher initial elevation, lower squat position, wider feet position after squatting, and less inclined arms. PCA^posture revealed significant timing differences in all components. We conclude, first, barbell load affects specific aspects of the movement pattern of the clean; second, the PCA^trial approach is better suited for detecting deviations from a mean motion trajectory and its results are easier to interpret; the PCA^posture approach reveals coordination patterns and facilitates comparisons of postural speeds and accelerations.

Keywords: clean; motion patterns; principal component analysis PCA; principal movements; technique analysis in sport; weightlifting.